Hello dear
Welcome To Tellers: An American Chophouse
Tellers: An American Chophouse, located in Islip, NY, is an exquisite dining destination that merges traditional steakhouse charm with modern elegance. Known for its prime cuts of steak, Tellers offers an impressive selection, including filet mignon and mouthwatering sides. Guests rave about the attentive service and inviting ambiance, making it perfect for special occasions. Iconic cocktails, like the Tellers Cosmo and Jalapeno Margarita, complement the dining experience. Patrons leave with memorable moments, as evidenced by heartwarming customer reviews. Whether celebrating anniversaries or enjoying a casual dinner, Tellers captures the essence of American chophouse cuisine beautifully.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Long Island Mule
Tellers Cosmo
Tellers Apple Martini
Jalapeno Margarita
About
Tellers: An American Chophouse
Welcome to Tellers: An American Chophouse, a destination that redefines the quintessential American steakhouse experience. Nestled in the heart of Islip, New York, this dining gem at 605 Main St brings together a modern flair and traditional roots, making it a must-visit for steak enthusiasts and food lovers alike.
As you step into Tellers, you’re enveloped by an inviting ambiance that perfectly complements the culinary artistry on the menu. The restaurant’s meticulous attention to detail is evident, from the elegant decor to the impeccable service. Customers rave about their experiences, with many highlighting the engaging staff who go above and beyond to make every meal feel special, whether you're celebrating an anniversary or simply indulging in a night out.
The star of the show, of course, is the steak. Reviews pour in echoing a consistent theme: the steaks here are nothing short of extraordinary. Patrons have praised the tender cuts, particularly the filet mignon, described as the best they’ve ever tasted. The menu showcases a variety of steak options that cater to every preference, making it easy to share a delightful tasting experience as you sample different cuts.
But Tellers is not just about its premium cuts of meat; the restaurant also excels in its innovative cocktails and delectable side dishes. Signature drinks like the Jalapeno Margarita and the Van Winkle Old Fashioned offer a refreshing twist on classic flavors, enhancing your dining experience. The creativity extends to appetizers, with dishes like the burrata and fig salad winning hearts with its exquisite balance of flavors. And don’t skip dessert; customers sing praises for the banana cream pie that rounds off your meal with the perfect sweet finish.
Whether you're a local resident or visiting from afar, Tellers promises an unforgettable dining experience with a focus on quality and service. As one frequent guest remarked, the restaurant's ability to create such memorable moments keeps them coming back year after year. For those who appreciate a modern take on an old-school steakhouse, Tellers is undoubtedly the place to be.
Plan your visit and prepare for a culinary journey that celebrates the heart of American dining, where exceptional food and warm hospitality converge.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Our experience at Tellers was beyond our expectations: Delicious Food, Impecable Service and engaging ambiance. Definitely We’ll go back. ”
“ Came here for me and my spouse's anniversary, they laid out a little thank you card at our table before we got there for celebrating it with them. Had the best filet mignon and banana creme pie of my life here. Our waiter was super nice and changed his demeanor to connect with us as people, super amazing dude. I spent around 300 for two people ( appetizer , two steaks , two sides , drinks , and a dessert that they customized for our anniversary ) before tip. It was absolutely worth the money. ”
“ Excellent service, steak is consistently delicious. Loved burrata and fig salad. Banana cake was excellent. Sparkling French bruit rose was perfect. Overall: excellent. ”
“ Fantastic. I travel all over the US for business and had a Long Island client recommend Tellers for a good steak dinner. I've been coming back every year since whenever I'm in town. ”
“ I don’t go to Teller’s enough but really should. Honestly, the food is really good. It’s based upon a traditional old-school steakhouse but the location is modern and beautiful. Steak lovers will love the selections. I usually order one 10-12 oz steak for both my wife and I as it’s enough for 2 people. ”
“ Love their Power Lunch! Got their apple pecan salad as my appetizer and their colossal pastrami sandwich and fries for my entree. I ended up taking 1/2 of my entree home. My friend and I split a dessert, which was out of this world. It was raspberry cream pie from a local farm out east on Long Island. Such a great deal at 29 for an incredible lunch! Our server, Luke, was also amazing. ”
“ Top of the line food with excellent service. The wellington was fantastic and this is the first time I've complimented the ginger ale I had. it was stunning. The best part for sure was the creme brulee. Best I've ever had ”
“ Food is always amazing and top notch. I've been coming here for almost 20 years and it never disappoints. Our latest visit was for our anniversary amd we had the Delmonico and a tomahawk tuna special. Both were incredible. Luke our server/bartender was on point and made this visit a fun and memorable experience. Thanks again Tellers for another amazing dining experience. ”